This article was sourced for a recent article in Hart’s E&P magazine, which can be found here.
Working, Together: RSS-Tailored Bit Designs Improve Drilling Performance
Written by: Aron Deen, Levi Sasser, and Chris Gooch
Nearly all new technologies struggle in their infancy to gain adoption due to high cost, problematic reliability, lack of understanding, and marginal value proposition. Over years of learning, development and refinement these hurdles reduce, and with each step new opportunities open up. This has been the case for rotary steerable systems (RSS), which is finding new value in this historic downturn.
Another facet of technology adoption is the availability of compliments. For example, smartphones need great apps for customers to realize their true value. In much the same way, RSS need to have great drill bits designed to work with them in order for operators to realize their maximum value.
To be sure, there are certainly some hurdles in working across company lines on product development. For example, gauge pad configuration is one of the many aspects of bit designs that are customized to work perfectly with differing RSS tools. Different lengths, steps, tapers, helix angles, and wear protection may be advantageous for a particular RSS application, but producing such a specific product requires a significant investment of engineering resources and capital. And once created, such a bespoke asset should not be blindly forced into an improper application to the detriment of another operator. The only long-term path over such hurdles is for service companies to jointly commit to focus first on performance for the customer.
World Record RSS runs in Eagle Ford
In South Texas, operators and RSS tool developers have toiled for the last few years to uncover the full value proposition of being able to steer while rotating. In theory, this should allow operators to capture all of the benefits of highly directional wells without the inefficiency of regularly having to interrupt operations to orient and slide at low ROP – and have better hole quality to go along with it. The increased complexity of the systems, however, requires all components to work together seamlessly. The primary challenge for operators has been maintaining ultra-tight windows in lateral applications of the extended-reach horizontals in the Eagle Ford. RSS has made those complex well designs a possibility.
Ulterra’s willingness to partner with RSS makers has contributed to great runs. After working with Weatherford to design an Eagle Ford bit tailored to Weatherford’s Revolution® RSS, there has been a huge improvement in vibration and torque, which has drastically reduced the chance of tool failure. At the same time, the bit is increasing ROP, setting distance records, and coming out of the hole in pristine condition.
In a run in Live Oak County, TX, the bit set three global footage records for the Revolution RSS by drilling 16,234 feet in one run. The extended-reach well had a total depth of 22,700 feet. Reaching out that far is a big challenge, and accomplishing it with one bottom-hole assembly had been previously unheard of. With the Ulterra bit and Weatherford RSS working together the BHA was able to stay on bottom for 192 hours.
Reduced Vibration, Improved Efficiency in Abu Dhabi
In a recent well in Abu Dhabi, a major operator encountered difficulty drilling through a troublesome series of formations in an ADMA brownfield while utilizing the AutoTrak X-treme™ motorized RSS from Baker Hughes. Based on data from their CoPilot™ system, vibration was identified to be one of the major performance limiting factors in two bits that had failed to complete the section. As this was the case, the operator turned to Ulterra to provide a custom solution.
One of the unique design technologies that Ulterra has to combat lateral vibration at the bit is CounterForce®, a novel cutter arrangement methodology that allows the cutters to work together to redirect vibrational energy back into the rock. By pairing this technology into a U713M bit design along with the RSS, the operator was able to complete the interval.
The Ulterra bit delivered, allowing the RSS assembly to drill 824 feet to section TD at an ROP of 23 ft/hr. This run was 66% faster than the average of the two previous bit runs in mother hole and 230% faster than the average of the two previous bit runs in pilot hole. According to the operator, this performance saved three trips. The dull condition was also excellent with only minimal abrasive wear to some of the cutters on the nose and shoulder.
More importantly to the operator, the MSE calculations from the CoPilot down hole measurement tool showed that the Ulterra bit, with CounterForce technology, achieved this using 14% less energy to drill compared to the previous runs that had mostly drilled in softer, easier formations. Vibration levels were also dramatically reduced in the most difficult formation where it causes the most issues. Compared to other bit runs, lateral vibrations and whirl were reduced by 84% and 31% respectively, while stick-slip was reduced by 88%.
Best for Best
Some RSS makers, such as Weatherford, Gyrodata, Scout Downhole, and others, focus their energy and expertise on their tools and services while leaving complimentary performance parts to other experts. Others produce their own OEM (original equipment manufacturer) drill bits, and obviously they will often recommend them with self-benefiting reasons. However, in high-cost, high-performance applications, which are often identifiable by the use of RSS, “stock” equipment is seldom the best option.
As a PDC drill bit company, Ulterra is always excited for the opportunity to tackle new and unique problems. Our mission is to be the most trusted employer and supplier of PDC drill bits in the industry, and to reward that trust with industry leading consistency, performance and relentless, rapid improvement. There are many great car makers, but they all rely on other companies for the best tires in the world. While Ulterra doesn’t make RSS tools, the evidence is growing that we do make the best bits for them.